And the glory which thou gavest me I have given them; that they may be one, even as we are one. — John 17:22
The phrase “Give glory to God” (Jos 7:19, Jer 13:16) is a Hebrew idiom meaning, “Confess your sins.” The words of the Jews to the blind man, “Give God the praise” (John 9:24) are an adjuration to confess. They are equivalent to, “Confess that you are an impostor,” “Give God the glory by speaking the truth;” for they denied that a miracle had been wrought. — Easton’s Bible Dictionary
For we do not dare to rank or compare ourselves with some of the ones commending themselves. But they, measuring themselves among themselves, and comparing themselves to themselves, are not perceptive. But we will not boast beyond measure, but according to the measure of the rule which the God of measure distributed to us, to reach even to you. For we do not overstretch ourselves as though not reaching to you. For we also came to you in the gospel of Christ; not boasting beyond measure in the labors of others, but having hope that the growing faith among you will be increased according to our rule, to overflowing; to preach the gospel in that beyond you, and not to boast in another’s rule in things made ready. But he who glories, let him glory in the Lord. For not he who commends himself is approved, but he whom the Lord commends. — 2 Corinthians 10:12-18
“Remember, everything we do gets hijacked by marketing.” That was the warning Sun Microsystems Inc. Chief Researcher John Gage had for developers working on emerging grid computing standards at the Global Grid Forum in Seattle in June, 2003. His comment reflects a general truth about what might be called marketing creep, the tendency toward the domination of marketing as the ultimate concern of every organization, including the church.
Church Growth, or the application of business marketing principles to the church, has been a thriving business for at least 25 years. I have studied and pondered the ways, means, issues and applications for most of that time. But something has troubled me about the effort to market Christ’s church. A dissonance in the pit of my stomach caught my attention early on, but identifying the source and nature of the my concern has proven to be difficult.
After all, I want the Lord’s people to reach out to lost sinners with the love of Christ. I don’t want churches to keep their proverbial lights under a bushel basket. We need to share our faith for the greater expansion of Christ’s church and the glory of God. These are all good things. The aim and purpose of church marketing or church growth appears to be a good thing. But is it?
I’m sure you can hear my hesitation about this noble effort to increase God’s Kingdom and Christ’s church. But please know from the outset that my hesitation is not related to the expansion of Christ’s church in the modern world. Lord knows, we need to capitalize on everything that will move the Kingdom forward. This article is not against evangelism or church growth.
Having worked in the area of secular marketing for a couple of years now, an insight and perspective about the problem with modern Church Growth and the Movement it inspired has finally jelled in my brain. The issue may be hard for you to see, it has certainly been hard for me to get a clear fix on it. Please bear with me.
I attended my first Church Growth workshop in 1982. There we learned how churches have failed to extend the most rudimentary business oriented hospitality to visitors. Visitors were described as potential customers for the services that churches should provide to their members. We learned about name tags and signage, parking and accessibility, friendliness and follow—up. In short, we learned to treat visitors and members like customers, and to better provide for their needs.
Honestly, at that time the people from the churches in attendance at that seminar were astonished by the lack of what might be call today a customer-centered approach to worship, the main attraction or venue for generating additional members, additional customers or more business. How could the churches be so out of touch with the people they professed to love and serve? We all went home with new resolve to become more visitor or customer—centered in our worship and programs.
The initial insight about name tags and signage, parking and accessibility, friendliness and follow-up was well received, as it should be. There’s nothing inherently wrong with these things.
As the Movement continued to develop momentum it began to apply its principles more and more widely, even to the content and choreography of the worship service itself. As marketing principles became more widely used in worship planning and execution, I became more and more disillusioned. But I could not put my finger on the nature of my concern.
The small churches that I served as pastor increasingly saw Church Growth principles as potentially answering many of their small church concerns. Noses and nickels became increasingly important to the governing boards, particular as they saw so many of their own young people abandon them and turn to modern churches that employed customer-centered marketing principles to every aspect of church life. Everything in such churches was done from the perspective of customer friendliness and ease of use. After all, these principles have clearly established themselves as engines that can—and have—grown phenomenal businesses and churches. Who can argue with success?
Nonetheless, some dissonance remained for me. I was not willing to turn the church over to the marketing department—denominational, local or parachurch. Something smelled wrong about it, but what was it?
Then it came to me in a flash.
Church members (or visitors) are not customers to the church, any more than family members (or children) are customers to their respective families. The church is not a business, it’s a family. Now, that does not mean that business and marketing principles cannot be successfully and effectively applied to churches. They can! But how they are applied makes all the difference in the world. There is nothing wrong with name tags and signage, parking and accessibility, friendliness and follow-up in and of themselves. Nor is there anything wrong with new church music.
However, the church is a service organization, not a sales organization. The purpose of the church is not to serve its members, but to serve the Lord Jesus Christ. Members are not to be the objects of service, but the vehicles of service. The difference involves a shift in philosophical or theological perspective.
If the old adage that the “customer is always right” is true, then church members are not customers, nor are church visitors. Rather, God is the only customer of the church. God is the only Person who is always right. And God is the One to receive the service, whether it’s a worship service, a prayer service or service to the community. It is done for the Lord, not primarily or directly for His people. We are to satisfy God, not ourselves or our church visitors.
This insight about church practice comes from the study of the Bible and its use and interpretation through the centuries. The traditional understanding of church practice was that the church is to be God-centered, not man-centered or woman-centered. God is the object of our service, not ourselves or each other-nor even the wider community.
With that fundamental insight the application of marketing or business principles can indeed be applied to the activities and practices of churches. But such application must always take a back seat to the prior concerns of God’s Word, historically understood and practiced.
In fact, the concern for church history is essentially a business marketing principle itself. Businesses keep records, and reports are made from those records. Any business worth its salt will know how it has performed in the past, so that it can endeavor to make improvements. And no business will simply abandon its past practices, but will only make well—planned, small, incremental adjustments to its activity or practice. History is a key element for business success, and is an essential element of Christianity.
The essential insight is that the worship and life of the church are not to be centered around the needs of its members, visitors, or the wider community, but around service to God as defined in the Bible. The people who attend worship are not themselves to be served. Rather, we worship as a service to God, just as we pray as a service to God, and reach out to a lost world in the service of God.
However, the bulk of the Church Growth Movement and its materials do not reflect this attitude. Rather, the Movement has succumbed to the urge to marketing. Marketing dominates the Church Growth Movement, and has eclipsed the biblical call to faithfulness. Faithfulness, not broad community appeal, is the highest priority of Christians and their churches.
The dangers inherent in the church growth movement are many, and the crucial issue in assessing those dangers is whether we are talking about becoming Christians or about building institutional membership. The greatest danger in the movement may be that it obviously succeeds. If one tailors the church to identify with its culture and engages in the pseudo-gospel of “possibility thinking,” promising to assuage guilt with the minimum of pain and connecting that promise with marketing techniques, there will be success. The question is whether the result will bear any similarity to the church.
—from Dangers of the Church Growth Movement, by Ralph H. Elliott.